Sharing Online Cultural Experiences: An Argument-Based Approach

Amgoud, Leila; Confalonieri, Roberto; De Jonge, Dave; d'Inverno, Mark; Hazelden, Katina; Osman, Nardine; Prade, Henri; Sierra, Carles and Yee-King, Matthew. 2012. 'Sharing Online Cultural Experiences: An Argument-Based Approach'. In: The 9th International Conference on Modeling Decisions for Artificial Intelligence. Girona, Spain 21 -23 November 2012. [Conference or Workshop Item]

No full text available

Abstract or Description

This paper proposes a system that allows a group of human users to share their cultural experiences online, like buying together a gift from a museum or browsing simultaneously the collection of this museum. We show that such application involves two multiple criteria decision problems for choosing between different alternatives (e.g. possible gifts): one at the level of each user, and one at the level of the group for making joint decisions. The former is made manually by the users via the WeShare interface. This interface displays an image with tags re?ecting some features (criteria) of the image. Each user expresses then his opinion by rating the image and each tag. A user may change his choices in light of a report provided by his WeShare agent on the opinion of the group. Joint decisions are made in an automatic way. We provide a negotiation protocol which shows how they are reached. Both types of decisions are based on the notion of argument. Indeed, a tag which is liked by a user constitutes an argument pro the corresponding image whereas a tag which is disliked gives birth to a cons argument. These arguments may have different strengths since a user may express to what extent he likes/dislikes a given tag. Finally, the opinion analysis performed by a WeShare agent consists of aggregating the arguments of the users.

Item Type:

Conference or Workshop Item (Paper)

Identification Number (DOI):


shared experiences; group decisions; argumentation

Departments, Centres and Research Units:

Computing > Embodied AudioVisual Interaction Group (EAVI)


November 2012Published

Event Location:

Girona, Spain

Date range:

21 -23 November 2012

Item ID:


Date Deposited:

24 Feb 2014 11:21

Last Modified:

20 Jun 2017 09:59


Edit Record Edit Record (login required)