‘His Spirit is in Action Seen’: Milton, Mrs Clive and the Simulacra of the Pastoral in Comus

Joncus, Berta. 2005. ‘His Spirit is in Action Seen’: Milton, Mrs Clive and the Simulacra of the Pastoral in Comus. Eighteenth-Century Music, 2(1), pp. 7-40. ISSN 1478-5706 [Article]

No full text available

Abstract or Description

This article explores the relationship between Drury Lane's most popular eighteenth-century masque, Comus (1738), and the contemporary fashions in politics, literature and recreation that informed it. On one level, the masque was a revival honouring Milton, the author of its libretto, in a manner consistent with his eighteenth-century reception: as a genius whose merit was just being recognized, and as a patriot hero whose incorruptibility mirrored the aspirations of those pledging allegiance to 'British' values.

On another level, however, the pastoral entertainment seems to have been mainly concerned with popular notions of female propriety and the challenges posed to those notions by the production's star soprano, Kitty Clive. Titillation was assured by interpolated musical scenes which had little to do with the libretto but much to do with composer Thomas Arne's mastery of the discursive techniques of ballad farce. The personality cult around Clive, the 'Goddess of Mirth', imposed upon the masque hermost celebratedmusical characterizations (both in the type of song and in the specific lyrics sung) to grant full voice to her flaunting of social codes.

The overwhelming success of Comus caused the masque to be reinvented as a public diversion at Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens by its owner, John Tyers. A Milton statue was erected in the gardens to preside over 'musical downs', where instrumentalists played hidden behind bushes to the north of 'The Temple of Comus'. Recontextualizing Comus at Vauxhall, Tyers created a site (nicknamed the 'Rendezvous of Cupid') in which lovers could further explore the transgressions of Mrs Clive's musical scenes within a simulated pastoral myth.

Item Type:


Identification Number (DOI):



Comus, Thomas Arne, Vauxhall Gardens, Kitty Clive, masque

Departments, Centres and Research Units:



January 2005Accepted
4 May 2005Published Online
March 2005Published

Item ID:


Date Deposited:

22 Mar 2024 14:24

Last Modified:

22 Mar 2024 14:24

Peer Reviewed:

Yes, this version has been peer-reviewed.



Edit Record Edit Record (login required)